Collingwoodfc.com.au has taken a look at each of the 12 matches since that late September night and broken down the moments that matter. During that 12 match stretch, Collingwood has won five games and Geelong seven. Of the four finals, the Magpies have only won one. But what a win it was.
Preliminary Final 2007
Geelong 13.14 (92) def. Collingwood 13.9 (87) at the MCG
Goals – Collingwood: Cloke 3, Medhurst 3, Didak 2, Rusling 2, Burns, O’Bree, Davis
Geelong: S.Johnson 3, Stokes 3, Mooney 2, G.Ablett 2, Kelly, Ottens, Chapman, Rooke
Disposals – Collingwood: H.Shaw 25, Swan 25, Clarke 21, Clement 21, Lockyer 20
Geelong: G.Ablett 31, Corey 31, Bartel 30, Ottens 23, S.Johnson 19, Byrnes 19, Mackie 19
Geelong entered the match red hot favourites but a gutsy Collingwood refused to give an inch. Despite its number one ruckman Fraser withdrawing on the eve of the match with a back injury, the Magpies hung in there all night long and were pushing deep inside 50 when the final siren sounded.
Round Nine 2008
Collingwood 20.14 (134) def. Geelong 7.6 (48) at the MCG
Goals – Collingwood: Cloke 4, Medhurst 3, Davis 2, Didak 2, Fraser, Johnson, Clarke, Bryan, Rocca, Pendlebury, H.Shaw, Lockyer, Thomas
Geelong: Ablett 2, Hawkins, Mooney, Gamble, Wojcinski, Varcoe
Disposals – Collingwood: Swan 29, Clarke 28, Didak 26, Pendlebury 26, Lockyer 23, H.Shaw 23
Geelong: Ablett 29, Corey 29, Enright 26, Ling 26, Mackie 25
After a whole summer to digest the Preliminary Final loss, Collingwood inflicted Geelong’s first defeat since round 21, 2007, and did so in convincing fashion. Collingwood kicked the first three goals of the night and set the tone for a game in which it produced an incredible 85 tackles. Lockyer, Burns and third gamer Wellingham led the way in the midfield while Rocca managed to quell Scarlett’s influence.
Round Three 2009
Geelong 18.14 (122) def. Collingwood 13.17 (95) at the MCG
Goals – Collingwood: Medhurst 3, Beams, L.Brown, Fraser, Cox, Lockyer, Thomas, Dick, Anthony, Didak, Davis
Geelong: Chapman 4, S.Johnson 3, Hawkins 2, Varcoe 2, Stokes 2, Mooney, Wojcinski, Byrnes, Ablett, Rooke
Disposals – Collingwood: Swan 30, Pendlebury 25, Cox 22, Beams 21, Lockyer 20, Thomas 20
Geelong: Ablett 37, Chapman 35, Bartel 28, Selwood 26, Enright 24
From the moment Leigh Brown missed a set shot at goal from point blank range only five minutes into the game, Collingwood could never quite get it right against the runners up of 2008. Geelong had the Easter Thursday match under wraps for most of the night and were rarely threatened en route to a 27-point win.
Preliminary Final 2009
Geelong 17.18 (120) def. Collingwood 6.11 (47) at the MCG
Goals – Collingwood: Didak, Johnson, O’Brien, L.Brown, Lockyer, Macaffer
Geelong: Chapman 25, Byrnes 2, Varcoe 2, Ablett 2, Hawkins 2, S.Johnson, Mooney, Corey, Ottens
Disposals – Collingwood: O’Bree 26, Didak 25, Johnson 22, Shaw 18, Swan 17, Thomas 17
Geelong: Ablett 34, Corey 34, Bartel 32, Selwood 29, Ling 27
Riding high after pinching the Semi-Final out of the grasp of a disbelieving Adelaide, Collingwood plunged down the emotional roller coaster of finals football and out of the 2009 finals series as the Cats stormed to a 73 point win. Pre-game rain meant that the surface was greasy early on but by the time it dried out the blue and white had all the answers. Johnson and O’Brien kicked the first two goals of the night but the Magpies could manage only four more for the remainder of the game (including none in the final quarter).
Round Nine 2010
Collingwood 6.14 (50) def. by Geelong 12.14 (86) at the MCG
Goals – Collingwood: Beams 4, O’Bree, Swan
Geelong: Mooney 3, Stokes 3, Johnson, Podsiadly, Ablett, Varcoe, Wojcinski, Hawkins
Disposals – Collingwood: Johnson 28, Ball 27, Swan 25, Shaw 25, Didak 20, D.Thomas 20, Wellingham 20
Geelong: Ablett 32, Kelly 32, Bartel 30, Milburn 30, Chapman 30
Having dropped both games to the Cats the year prior, Collingwood entered the match eager to make amends and looked every chance of doing so when Beams kicked two goals in the shadows of half time to trail by only five points at the main break. An O’Bree goal six minutes into the third quarter put the Magpies 10 points up and was followed by behinds to Davis, Johnson and Thomas in the space of three minutes. Incredibly, an 11-point lead evaporated and was quickly replaced by a 22-point deficit at the final change. For the second time in a row, the Magpies went goalless in the final quarter as Geelong stormed to a six goal win.
Round 19 2010
Collingwood 14.23 (107) def. Geelong 12.13 (85) at the MCG
Goals – Collingwood: Beams 3, Cloke 2, Wellingham 2, Johnson, Jolly, D.Thomas, Macaffer, Swan, L.Brown
Geelong: Stokes 3, Johnson 2, Ablett, Corey, Selwood, Varcoe, Byrnes, Podsiadly
Disposals – Collingwood: Didak 35, Swan 32, Pendlebury 24, Wellingham 23, D.Thomas 23
Geelong: Ablett 26, Enright 24, Chapman 23, Selwood 23, Ling 21, Milburn 21
There was plenty at stake for Mick Malthouse’s men. They entered the match with six consecutive wins behind them and keen to knock off Geelong for the first time in two years. After a tight first half, Johnson steadied the ship with a trademark long goal from outside 50m just as it appeared Geelong was going to put the Pies to the sword. Instead, Collingwood went on to boot another three goals to Cloke, Thomas and Beams and led by 13 points at the final break. Goals to Jolly and Beams iced the game, the Maggies home by 22 points.
Preliminary Final 2010
Collingwood 18.12 (120) def. Geelong 11.13 (79) at the MCG
Goals – Collingwood: Cloke 3, Swan 2, Sidebottom 2, Pendlebury 2, Wellingham 2, L.Brown, Johnson, D.Thomas, Macaffer, Didak, Dawes, Beams
Geelong: Byrnes 2, Varcoe 2, Stokes 2, Mooney, Ottens, Johnson, Podsiadly, Bartel
Disposals – Collingwood: Swan 33, Didak 28, Pendlebury 24, Johnson 22, D.Thomas 21
Geelong: Ablett 40, Corey 30, Bartel 29, Ling 29, Johnson 28
One of the most famous nights in Collingwood history. With the weight of expectation on their shoulders, the young Magpies sensed the occasion and seized the moment with a seven goal to one opening quarter. From Leigh Brown’s goal from 75m that bounced the ‘wrong’ way twice to Johnson’s sidestep around Ling, the quarter was a half hour highlights reel. The near-capacity crowd expected Geelong to fight back hard but was shocked when the Magpies burst out of the middle for Sidebottom to goal only 35 seconds into the second quarter. By now, the die had been cast and although the Cats managed eight of the last 10 goals it was cold comfort in Gary Ablett’s final game for Geelong. For the record, Ablett managed 40 possessions.
Round Eight 2011
Geelong 8.17 (65) def. Collingwood 9.8 (62) at the MCG
Goals – Collingwood: Cloke 2, Sidebottom 2, Krakouer, D.Thomas, Swan, L.Brown, Pendlebury
Geelong: Bartel 2, Podsiadly, Stokes, Kelly, Johnson, Varcoe, Christensen
Disposals – Collingwood: Swan 30, Shaw 27, D.Thomas 26, Buckley 26, Sidebottom 22
Geelong: Corey 31, Selwood 29, Johnsn 25, Kelly 22, Chapman 20
Most presumed that Geelong would fall off the pace and the Magpies continue with their winning ways as 2011 got underway, but by round eight it was clear that the Cats weren’t going anywhere. Collingwood led by five points at three quarter time and nearly snuck over the line when Pendlebury goaled from a stoppage after Wood was infringed. Curiously, the umpire opted not to pay advantaged and forced Wood to take his kick from 60m out. The clock then ticked down into the 28th minute and sounded time on Collingwood’s first loss for the season.
Round 24 2011
Collingwood 8.5 (53) def. by Geelong 22.17 (149) at the MCG
Goals – Collingwood: Dawes 2, Blair, Pendlebury, Wood, Beams, Krakouer, Fasolo
Geelong: Menzel 5, Chapman 3, Christensen 3. Podsiadly 2, Johnson 2, Hawkins 2, Varcoe 2, Wojcinski, Duncan, Mackie
Disposals – Collingwood: Pendlebury 30, Beams 29, Didak 27, Swan 25, Sidebottom 24
Geelong: Kelly 29, Chapman 28, Duncan 26, Johnson 25, Bartel 24
A game Collingwood supporters want to forget. The two teams occupied the top two spots on the ladder (the Magpies having already locked in top spot for the second successive year) but you would never have known it once the Cats got out the gate in the second quarter. After the Pies kicked the first four goals of the night, Geelong kicked 22 of the last 26 goals to win by 96 points. All of this in the season in which the Magpies were kicking big scores in their sleep. On the eve of the finals, it wasn’t a good portent of things to come.
Grand Final 2011
Collingwood 12.9 (81) def. by Geelong 18.11 (119) at the MCG
Goals – Collingwood: Cloke 3, Krakouer 3, Sidebottom 2, L.Brown, Johnson, Wellingham, Ball
Geelong: Johnson 4, Hawkins 3, Varcoe 3, Bartel 3, Selwood 2, Stokes, Duncan, Ling
Disposals – Collingwood: Pendlebury 33, Thomas 31, Johnson 26, Sidebottom 23, Shaw 22
Geelong: Selwood 28, Bartel 26, Corey 25, Chapman 24, Varcoe 21
So near yet so far. When Geelong spearhead Podsiadly went down with a dislocated shoulder at one end and Krakouer floating across a pack to mark at the other to put Collingwood three goals in front midway through the second quarter, Pies fans began to believe that premiership No. 16 was on its way. Let’s leave it there.
Round Eight 2012
Collingwood 14.12 (96) def. Geelong 11.18 (84) at the MCG
Goals – Collingwood: Pendlebury 4, Fasolo 3, Cloke 2, Goldsack 2, Dawes, Swan, Blair
Geelong: Stokes 3, Hawkins 2, Podsiadly 2, Duncan 2, Chapman, Motlop
Disposals – Collingwood: Sidebottom 38, Pendlebury 30, Shaw 30, Beams 28, Swan 27
Geelong: Selwood 36, Kelly 26, Enright 25, Chapman 24, Corey 24
This wasn’t redemption for the losses 12 months prior, but it was still sweet nonetheless. Scores were level with only minutes to play but Collingwood somehow summoned the strength to pull away at the last second. A lucky 50m penalty to Fasolo brought him within 40m from goal. Moments later, Pendlebury finished off the game in style with a goal from the centre square that appeared destined to bounce through for a behind.
Round 16 2012
Geelong 10.19 (79) def. Collingwood 17.8 (110) at the MCG
Goals – Collingwood: D.Thomas 3, Tarrant 2, Dawes 2, Beams 2, Goldsack 2, Fasolo 2, Elliott, Jolly, Maxwell, Cloke
Geelong: Stokes 3, Johnson 2, Ablett, Corey, Selwood, Varcoe, Byrnes, Podsiadly
Disposals – Collingwood: Swan 40, Beams 36, Pendlebury 36, Shaw 29, Sidebottom 22
Geelong: Kelly 38, Johnson 36, Enright 25, Selwood 23, Corey 21
The scene was set when Collingwood kicked eight goals to two in the opening quarter. There were shades of the 2010 Preliminary Final in the way the Magpies were kicking their goals but the highlight of the night was undoubtedly Tarrant’s two goals in his return to the forward line. Maxwell kicked his first goal since early 2009 and Thomas’ three goals and 15 possessions helped take the game right out of Geelong’s reach.